What Happens When Your First Customer Is an AI?

Written by Mark SoaresDate May 15, 2025

What Happens When Your First Customer Is an AI? thumbnail

Humans still click the buttons. But increasingly, it’s their AI that reads your site first—and we’re not designing for that reality yet.

Right now, every customer is a human. Every metric, every headline, every CTA is engineered for human eyes. But that window is closing.

In the not-too-distant future, your customer’s first interaction with your brand won’t be a person—it’ll be their AI. Not a sentient being with feelings or preferences, but a utility. An agent. A parser. A proxy. Its job? To gather, sort, and filter everything before the human sees it. And if your website or product doesn’t speak its language, you might never get the chance to pitch the actual buyer.

This shift won’t be driven by sci-fi robots or general intelligence. It’ll come from something far more boring: productivity. People are busy. AI is good at skimming. Whether it’s an executive using an agent to shortlist vendors or a consumer automating travel planning, we’re moving into a world where “conversion” starts with code, not cognition.

From Mobile-First to AI-First

This is the same pattern we saw during the shift from desktop to mobile. First it was a nice-to-have. Then it became survival. The responsive web emerged because humans were increasingly coming in through smaller screens, and the friction was killing sales.

We’re about to see a similar bifurcation—but not based on screen size. Based on species.

There will be human-facing websites. Rich, visual, emotional, brand-heavy. And there will be AI-facing websites. Stripped down, structured, API-rich, documentation-forward. Think less “landing page” and more “knowledge graph endpoint.”

The split may start subtly—structured data layers, embedded schema, clean documentation, explainer JSON. But over time, the best-performing companies may build entirely separate AI-facing interfaces: fast, minimal, unbranded, optimized for agent parsing. A second front-end, built for bots.

Why This Isn’t Just SEO 2.0

Yes, this sounds a little like SEO. But it’s deeper than that. SEO was about surfacing content to humans via intermediaries (search engines). This is about intermediaries acting on behalf of humans entirely. They don’t just find your page—they decide whether their human ever sees it. That’s a new kind of gatekeeper.

And unlike humans, AIs don’t care about your vibes. They don’t get emotionally manipulated by color gradients or brand voice. They evaluate relevance, precision, and permission. If your product documentation is vague, your pricing hidden, or your integration story unclear, the agent might auto-filter you out. You won’t even know you lost the sale.

What It Means for Builders

You’ll need to design for two audiences—one emotional, one computational.

The human side wants story, beauty, connection. The AI side wants clarity, context, and endpoints. If you’re hiding your value prop behind clicky animations or burying your pricing behind a sales call, the human might forgive you. Their AI won’t.

Expect to see new tools emerge that help companies build “AI-visible” websites. Think agent parsers, bot-UX testing, machine-readable interaction flows. There will be firms optimizing for LLM summarization just like they used to optimize for search crawlers.

And eventually, AI agents will start transacting. Not just recommending. Not just summarizing. Buying. Booking. Committing. At that point, you’re not just designing for an assistant—you’re designing for your actual customer.

This Is Already Starting

There are early signs. People are using ChatGPT to research products and paste in pricing pages. Devs are plugging in AI assistants to pull docs, compare vendors, and prep team briefings. AI-first interfaces—like Notion’s AI summaries, or Zapier’s agent workflows—are already filtering the web for us.

Once these tools get integrated into our calendars, inboxes, and wallets, the line between user and user-agent will blur completely. When someone asks “who’s visiting your site,” you may not be able to say with confidence that it was a person.

The TL;DR

Humans are still your buyers. But they may not be your users—not at first. As AI agents take over the first touchpoint, the companies that succeed will be the ones who learn to speak fluently to both sides of the interface.

The website of the future isn’t one site. It’s two.

And the faster you start building for both, the fewer opportunities your parser will quietly miss.